Sahih Al-Bukhari Hadith - 2.321

Prev    Next   
Narrated Abu Huraira

The Prophet offered one of the evening prayers (the sub-narrator Muhammad said, "I think that it was most probably the 'Asr prayer") and he finished it after offering two Rakat only. He then stood near a piece of wood in front of the Mosque and put his hand over it. Abu Bakr and 'Umar were amongst those who were present, but they dared not talk to him about that (because of excessive respect for him), and those who were in a hurry went out. They said, "Has the prayer been reduced?" A man who was called Dhul-Yadain by the Prophet said (to the Prophet), "Has the prayer been reduced or have you forgotten?" He said, "Neither have I forgotten, nor has the prayer been reduced." He said, "Certainly you have forgotten." So the Prophet offered two more Rakat and performed Taslim and then said Takbir and performed a prostration of Sahu like his ordinary prostration or a bit longer and then raised his head and said Takbir and then put his head down and performed a prostration like his ordinary prostration or a bit longer, and then raised his head and said Takbir.

PDF content
Tags 


No tags assigned yet.

Share your thoughts about this with others by posting a comment. Visit our FAQ for some ideas.

Comment Filters >>
Filter Comments  

search-icon
User Roles  
Groups  

hadith_comment

User

2

 
  votes      1
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi    
  3 years 29 weeks ago
This hadith is not sahi. The Holy Prophet (saw) is infallible and a living Quran. He cannot forget a prayer. Sura al-Najm testifies about the Holy prophet's infallibility so does surah 33 verse 33.
User

1

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Syed Husain   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  3 years 29 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to Syed Husain 
  3 years 29 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Syed Husain   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  3 years 29 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to Syed Husain 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Syed Husain   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to Syed Husain 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  mohammed hannini   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to mohammed hannini 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  mohammed hannini   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to mohammed hannini 
  3 years 27 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  irumbokhari   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  29 weeks 6 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Syed Husain   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  3 years 27 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to Syed Husain 
  3 years 27 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  mohammed hannini   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to mohammed hannini 
  28 weeks 6 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  mohammed hannini   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

1

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to mohammed hannini 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

1

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Vajeeha Rizvi   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  1 year 35 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Abdur Rahim   in reply to mohammed hannini 
  3 years 27 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  baghdadi   in reply to mohammed hannini 
  1 year 12 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Wafaa   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  1 year 11 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  M.usman   in reply to  
  1 year 10 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Jamil Ghani   in reply to  
  1 year 8 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  irumbokhari   in reply to  
  29 weeks 6 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Imran Haqiim   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  42 weeks 6 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ashfaq Shaikh   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  28 weeks 6 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to  
  28 weeks 6 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ashfaq Shaikh   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  28 weeks 6 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ashfaq Shaikh   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  28 weeks 5 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Ali   in reply to Syed Husain 
  45 weeks 1 hour ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Paper man   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  3 years 29 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi   in reply to Paper man 
  3 years 28 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Jamil Ghani   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  1 year 8 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  AbuIlyaasHakimD...   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  1 year 5 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Valon Alili   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  33 weeks 6 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Valon Alili   in reply to Ali Naqvi 
  33 weeks 6 days ago
User

1

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Samyyah    
  1 year 48 weeks ago
Asalaamu-Alaykum,

In reply to all of the comments and replies in this forum I would simply like to add a viewpoint to the ongoing discussion.  Would it be a great possibility that our beloved Prophet and Messenger, may the peace and blessings of ALLAH be upon him, have simply performed the steps of what "WE" are to do when we forget a prayer?  The inclusion of our Prophets' response of, "Neither have I forgotten, nor has the prayer been reduced" is a clear indication that holds affirm to Islam being a complete religion.  This particular hadith provides the exact steps in what to do when one forgets a prayer.  Asalaamu-Alaykum.    
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Pip Power    
  1 year 37 weeks ago

Today the religion of Islam is constantly in the news because of its violence. Many people know that Islam is violent but know little else about the religion. A few people know a little about Muhammad. He was a successful leader, he suffered harsh persecution, endured famine and poverty, remained steadfast in the face of opposition, loved his followers dearly, and created the 2nd largest religion in the world.. But there is more to Islam and Muhammad that needs to be understood. Muhammad had a superstitious, somewhat bizarre, set of religious beliefs.

This article presents a short account of Muhammad’s superstitions regarding various animals. Some of these superstitions have been written about in detail elsewhere. Here, I’ll provide the basics and leave you to do the thinking and assessment. The pity is that Muhammad’s beliefs, including his superstitions, form the basis of faith for some one billion followers today. Today, these unfortunate people are bound in a system of belief that shackles their minds with superstition and inhibits them from knowing God and His plan for them.

 

MUHAMMAD AND THE JEWS: PIGS & APES & RATS & LIZARDS

The Quran contains myths about Jews and Christians. Three of the Quranic verses that reflect these myths are 2:63 – 65, 5:60, and 7:166. All quotes are from "The Noble Quran" [1].


2:63 – 65
And (O Children of Israel, remember) when We took your covenant and We raised above you the Mount (saying): "Hold fast to that which We have given you, and remember that which is therein so that you may become Al-Muttaqun. Then after that you turned away. Had it not been for the Grace and Mercy of Allah upon you, indeed you would have been among the losers. And indeed you knew those amongst you who transgressed in the matter of the Sabbath. We said to them: "Be you monkeys, despised and rejected."

5:60
Say (O Muhammad to the people of the Scripture): "Shall I inform you of something worse than that, regarding the recompense from Allah: those (Jews) who incurred the Curse of Allah and His Wrath, those of whom (some) He transformed into monkeys and swines, those who worshipped Taghut (false deities); such are worse in rank (on the Day of Resurrection in the Hellfire), and far more astray from the Right Path."

7:166
So when they exceeded the limits of what they were prohibited, We said to them: "Be you monkeys, despised and rejected." (It is a severe warning to the mankind that they should not disobey what Allah commands them to do, and be far away from what He prohibits them).

User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Syed Husain   in reply to Pip Power 
  1 year 37 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Pip Power   in reply to Syed Husain 
  1 year 36 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Syed Husain   in reply to Pip Power 
  Edited (6)
  1 year 8 months ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Pip Power   in reply to Syed Husain 
  1 year 35 weeks ago
User

1

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Asifuddin Muhammed   in reply to Pip Power 
  1 year 32 weeks ago
User

1

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  luna soles   in reply to Pip Power 
  1 year 35 weeks ago
User

1

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Jegam Ali Siddiqui    
  1 year 35 weeks ago
With all my observations and logic, brother Ali Naqvi wins this series....
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Jegam Ali Siddiqui    
  1 year 35 weeks ago
We all are Muslims and believers....we may be in three sects Jews, Christians and Islam but finally we all are Muslims i.e. believers
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  sadaf    
  1 year 31 weeks ago
Ali Naqvi May Allah bless you. You just guided me and answered all my questions in a perfect way with reference which I referred to. People need to remember Qur'an 1st then hadith. I read both and the hadith contradicts the holy Quran. but some just read one with out the other. While reading the Quran 15:35-42Allah says to iblis- "as for my servants you have no authority over them" Allah protects them and iblis says i will put them all in the wrong except the servent's among them sincere and purified by your grace (lord). So people please I beg you, instead of arguing with ali naqvi please ask yourself this simple common sense question and forget about infallibility or fallibility, A human being tells me to pray and do it on time and not eat harm and not act in a harm way and pay charity because it was told by Allah and say's to do so in the Quran but the human being that is telling me is not doing the same and not doing what he/she was telling me, would or should I listen to such a  person? MY ANSWER WOULD BE NOOOOO.Hypocrite!!! I as a human being needs a leader or a role model to look up to and that role model has to be a prefect example for me as a Muslim so the hadith's tell me that prophet Mohammad (peace be upon him) slipped not once not twice not three times but many many times so what makes him a Prophet of Allah? If the Quran says don't listen to sinful people don't listen to music (31:6) and prophet Mohammad told abu bakir to leave aisha a lone when abu bakir was yelling at aisha for having girls come over to play music in the prophets home and in the presents of the prophet because its eid??(Sahihi bakhari) doesn't make sense to me . if the Quran says something is harm it makes it harm all times not special occasions or when your tired or ill or its eid or wedding or the only meat around is pork. The Quran says do not raise your voice over the prophet then why did Umar and his other followers do it in sahihi bakhari vol 1 book 3 number 114 when Prophet Mohammad said to bring writing material and he will write something that will prevent ppl from going astray and Umar among others prevented him by screaming and shouting angering the prophet so bad the the prophet has to tell them to get out of the room and if the prophet wanted to write something to guide me I would let him and not question it and say the Quran is sufficient and he is talking nonsense or he is just ill and is not aware of what he is doing, then I thought to myself the shia's are right, it had to be something Umar and other members didn't want. it had to be Imam Ali's Name. Common sense told me this..the hadith is stories not tafsir written by people so 1st quran then hadith's. IN MY OPINION the Hadith's of the sunnah made the prophet seem to be lower then the leaders and that the prophet wouldn't be a prophet with out the guidance of abu bakir and umar..Uthman and imam ali is hardly mentioned and of course aisha prevented him for further being a leader and forces him to reside..people please do your research as i did from our own books..this is y people sin and say its ok Allah forgives..yes Allah forgives but forgives unintentional sins not intentional sins..do it and forgive is not the way know and don't do it is the way. All i know is a human being needs a sinless leader like prophet Mohammad mentioned in the Quran not like Prophet Mohammad mentioned in the hadith. i am not an expert but i know enough to choose whats right for me and whats wrong for me by educating my self and stop my self from being ignorant and talk nonsense read the books that Ali jan has mentioned and educate yourselfs from your own book but before that read the quran there are many types of translations and try to create your own translation if u must. we all agree that Allah put us on the earth to be tested but who fails and who passes is up to us and we can not determine that with out knowledge. I heard the Prophet saying, "there will be twelve Muslim rulers (who will rule all the Islamic world)." He then said a sentance which i did not hear. my father said," all of them (those rulers) will be from Quraish" sahih bakhari volume 9, book 89 number 329 also mentioned and sahih muslim and all the sunni books look for it yourself's and stop being lazy. ALLAH BLESS ALL AND GUIDE THEM TO THE RIGHT PATH.
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Abu Ilyaas Damulira    
  1 year 5 weeks ago
I want mr. Ali Naqvi and anyone who supports him to answer my query.  If the rasool is not capable of forgetting, then explain to all of us why and how it is related that he was made to forget the night of power ( laylatul qadr ).  This is why we look for it in the odd nights of the last 10 days of ramadhaan.  Please answer that.  
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Yawar Hussain   in reply to Abu Ilyaas Damulira 
  1 year 4 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Ali   in reply to Abu Ilyaas Damulira 
  45 weeks 1 hour ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  khaniqbal46    
  1 year 3 weeks ago

       Required Fatwa


Assalam u Alaikum,                                                                     date-28.08.2013

Larki apne office ke kaam se gai aur waha per us ka ghar bhi hian to wo ghar per ruki. Hamari ammi se khuch an-ban bhi hoti rahti thi tabhi larki ke mama ne hamare father ko bola ki larki divorce maag rahi hain aur father ke dost se bhi phone karke 2 baar bola lakin larki se puchne per larki ne mana kar diya.hum larki ko ghar ane ke liye bol rahe thain un ka kahna tha ki hum ammi ke sath nhi rahege hume alag laker rakho aur is baat ko hum raazi nhi thain tabi hum ne guse me akar apni biwi se bole ki hum tum ko talak deta hain. Us doran hamara bacha uske pait me tha.Us ke baad bhi hamari batein hoti rahi daily khuch dino baad larki ke ghar walo ne job ke liye larki ko delhi bhej diya hamara ghar nhi bheja aur na hi masle ka hal kara  isi guse me aa kar ki larki hamare ghar nhi ai aur kahi rah rahi hain hum ne use bahut galia di aur ulta siddha bhi kahan aur uski ammi ko bhi bola. Aur khuch dino baad sms bhi kar diya ki idat ka din mubarak hou,lakin wo idat ,me nhi bethi thi aur phir hamare sath baat chit bhi hoti rahi daily doni ki raza bandi se aur hum do baar mile bhi aur ghume bhi gai. Aur baad me humne bola ki hum blaack dete hain meri biwi ka kahna hain ki usne talak world suna hain lakin hum ne ye nhi bola aur uske baad bhi hum milte rahe aur batein bhi hoti rahi daily. aur ye sari batein sirf phone per bola aur larki ne suna aur  koi gawah bhi na tha to hadis ke hisab se wo hamare nikah me hain ya nahi

 

biwi ka kahna hain ki talak teen martaba bole diya aur humara kahana hain ki ek martaba bola hain aur baki baar blaak bola hian

Regards

Iqbal khan

Mail id -khaniqbal46@gmail.com

User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Anjaana   in reply to  
  40 weeks 4 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Sulaiman Gafoor    
  1 year 3 weeks ago
ALLAH is infallible. The Prophet Muhammad was but a prophet - Though the most perfect of creation. He was sinless, but he could forget as well as a human.

Also, Bukhari is of the صحاح الست. The Saheeh 6.

Islaam is a monotheistic religion.

As muslims, people should be able to know that by now.

Also, for interest's sake:
مسلم = One who makes peace;
So make peace.
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Sulaiman Gafoor   in reply to Sulaiman Gafoor 
  1 year 3 weeks ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Ali   in reply to Sulaiman Gafoor 
  45 weeks 1 hour ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Ali   in reply to Sulaiman Gafoor 
  45 weeks 2 min ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Imad Sibhai    
  43 weeks 2 days ago
hi friends just wanted to share my hadith website who want to be aurthor please send me email at:imadisibhai@gmail.com

My website:
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Nehal Shah   in reply to Imad Sibhai 
  43 weeks 1 day ago
User

1

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Anjaana    
  40 weeks 4 days ago
Dear brothers in Islam, Believe what Allah has said in the Quran. Do not waste your energies , time and deeds in trying to prove that Mohammed (pbuh) was an ordinary creature like you and me.
If angles can be made of noor is it difficult for Allah to make Mohammed(pbuh) of special creation.
He made Adam from no parents, Jesus(pbuh) from only mother, so is it difficult  for him to make Mohammed (pbuh) from his own light.
There were munafiqs at the time of the prophet (pbuh) and now we have their progeny doing the same work.
Hadiths are written by human beings and are subject to errors and manupulations .
Quran is the ultimate guide and has no comparision whatsoever. It is sufficient initself and does not require the support of any Bukhari, Tirmidhi, Suyuti or  any Tom, dick and harry.


User

1

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Anjaana    
  40 weeks 4 days ago
Today when you doubt that Mohammed (pbuh) is from Allah's noor , you should also doubt that Isa (pbuh) is Ruhullah. Please rest your little minds to peace. The knowledge of Allah and Mohammed(pbuh) cannot be comprehended by your little brains.
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Anjaana    
  40 weeks 4 days ago
How I wish that people with poor and low IQ had not entered Islam. 
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Valon Alili   in reply to  
  33 weeks 6 days ago
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi    
  33 weeks 6 days ago
Quran- Surah al Najm:
I swear by the star when it goes down. (53:1)
Your companion does not err, nor does he go astray; (53:2)
Nor does he speak out of desire. (53:3)

Is that proof enough??
User

0

 
  votes      0
  dislikes
  Ali Naqvi    
  33 weeks 6 days ago
Salamun Alaykum forum members,
I see that some members have asked me question. I can reply with Quran as my witness.
I will use Quran only so do not worry :)
One thing though which I would like, is for you all to stop posting so that I can answer. So many posts have been written after my post 2 years ago.

If you all are okay with this, I will from the Quran show you that Prophet Muhammad (saw) was the first creation ever made, even before Prophet Adam (As). I will then also prove to you that he was NOT merely a human being and could err etc.
Astarghfurullah.
For those of you who claim that Sahi Sittah is 100% authentic, have NOT read the narrations in these books. :) 

Tell me when to start. Remember, the only way to understand the true meaning of the Quran is through Ahl Ul Bait (as) as stated in the following Narration:

http://www.alim.org/library/hadith/SHM/1112
Bookmark
Clip page
Subscribe